Tuesday, 15 October 2013
The transatlantic slave trade was a cruel and vile example of persecution. Countries, companies and governments who were involved should try to repair the harm they caused. How far do you agree with this statement?
Use all your knowledge about the transatlantic slave trade and the sources to help you
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Useful Links
- Cameron's ancestors received compensation
- We must be honest about our role in the slave trade
- Britains colonial shame
- University College London Legacies of British Slave Ownership
- Compensation culture gone crazy?
- Were your family 'slave owners'?
- George Orwell family among 3,000 slave-owners who received compensation
The transatlantic slave-trade cruel and vile as many slaves were kidnapped and taken in as prisoners to work on plantations. I think countries, companies and government who were involved should repair the harm they caused. Compensation has been given to people such as David Cameron whose ancestor was a slave owner.
ReplyDeleteCompensation should be given to the descendants of slavery because there ancestors were forced into becoming slaves which was unfair as slaves were actually educated and had a lot of potential and could have done something with their lives.However all this was taken away from them as they were kidnapped and make to work.
I agree. I think that companies that were around back then during the slave trade SHOULD pay for the damage they have caused because they used slaves in cruel manners just to get money for their own economies and slaves didn't get anything out of this, Some Countries should also pay compensation because they used and abused slaves and traded them for different things, again, making their own money.
ReplyDeleteI also think that compensation should be given to the descendants of slaves as it is not fair that the descendant’s ancestors have gone through all this hardship without being recognized or reconciled and I personally think compensation can help towards it. Although it won’t make up for the immense damage caused by Britain and other countries it help be a symbol for the appropriate appreciation we would show by paying compensation. The fact that slave owners descendants are being paid compensation is not fair as they never went through any hardships, they are getting money for virtually doing nothing. The majority people who have received compensation as they are descendants of slave owners are already wealthy people such as David Cameron, I think compensation should also apply to slaves descendants as their ancestors have suffered traumatic experiences as they were slaves. Although the descendants of slaves have never suffered slavery themselves, why should wealthy people such as David Cameron be paid compensation and not descendants of slaves themselves. Slave owners destroyed the life of slaves and took away their rights to education, freedom of speech etc, they could have been educated and be allowed to prosper and grow as they had a lot of potential to. I agree with the fact that descendants of slaves should be payed compensation.
ReplyDeleteThe transatlantic slave trade was a devious but cunning plan to earn a heap load of money for the nation. It had ripped families and friends apart and separated them for their homes. Basically in the beginning, the British colonies shipped manufacture’s materials to West Africa. The materials Britain carried were guns liquor and more. Majority of the black Africans slaves were kidnapped from their homes. When the British colonies imprisoned the black Africans they then sailed them to the Caribbean to be auctioned or traded for raw materials such as tobacco, sugar and cotton. These goods were sailed back to Britain. This business made Britain the richest country in the world at that time. Sending a message to the rest of the world that they have power and with that a great responsibility. This made the Africans miserable and really frightened. There weren't any fun joys or laughter any more on the streets of West Africa where families were torn. I believe the nation which has contributed to make Africa a terrible place by lowering the income of the country. Slavery existed in the 15th century. Slavery occurred mostly because Britain wanted more money and the King of Britain wanted to show the rest of the world who is the boss and ruler of the world. The transatlantic slave trade made Britain the richest country in the world at that time. By the way this class is A..W.E.S.O.M.E with the capital SHAMSHER Halla
ReplyDeleteHi
ReplyDeleteI think we all agree with this statement 9yHi1. What we need to do is move beyond saying, I agree. Now start using the articles and information in the useful links to inform our opinions. Select evidence from there to justify your opinions. Considerable research has been done about the issue of slavery and reparations by University College London. You need to use their information, database and research to help inform your work. Bismah, Shamsher, Juwairiyyah and Usmaan – well done for contributing first. Now read the information and research about reparations and post a comment which clearly demonstrates you have engaged with the material I have selected for you!
I think the transatlantic slave trade was very mean and cruel and also very greedy. The Europeans were very selfish and cold hearted to see people suffer because of them. the slave trade was unfair but Africa is to be blamed abit as if they had a strong army and weapons then the Europeans would have never succeeded at there kidnapping. Africa had alot of money and power, so they should have known that they had to protect it together from others however they were kidnapped and used in the slave trade. After many years they were punished and made to work hard slavery was abolished thanks to the black people rebelling, white people campaigning and the economy drop. soon the slave trade was worth it as they could get cheaper sugar and tobacco from Cuba and the cost of owning and feeding and housing a slave was expensive. so they rather have the slaves free and working for a low wage. the silly thing is the slave owners were compensated millions of pounds in today's money for the loss of there property. i think the government and prime minister should pay at least half back as it was Europe fault and David Camerons ancestors were slave owners that gained 3 million in today money which gives even more of a reason to give money back to Africa which is suffering now.
ReplyDeleteI believe the Transatlantic was a very cruel and devastating process .The Europeans(especially Britain) were remorseless and wicked people,became they were making profit with the slaves's misfortunes as they were getting punished severely and up-most barbarically.This process led Britain to become the wealthiest place around.Nevertheless they were clever in numerous ways.
ReplyDeleteHowever I believe that the descendants of slaves should be enabled to get compensation ,even though. it would not bring back those innocent and vulnerable lives of discriminated slaves.David Cameron's family are already quite wealthy people even though they were slave owners they still got compensation.I believe that is not right because I think compensation should ONLY be given to those descendants whose ancestors have come across traumatizing and reckless times.
The source-"George Orwell family among 3,000 slave-owners who received compensation." states how he was one of the descendants of slaves who was reassured a absolutely splendid 20 million which is like 1.8 billion in today's rates.Because of that massive amount of finance people are going mad that is why according to George "One of the things we found is that far from the slave owners all being concentrated in the great slaving ports of London, Liverpool, Glasgow and Bristol, there are people all over the country making claims of compensation."
The transatlantic slave trade was a cruel and vile example of persecution. Countries, companies and governments who were involved should not pay compensation to the descendants of slaves, even though the crime of slavery is a unforgivable act you will never be able to properly punish someone as the perpetrators of the crimes are dead and it is unjust to punish someone die to the actions of their ancestors also another fact to consider is why should the descendants of slaves get compensation as they did not feel the true pain of slavery so in truth no one deserves to be punished or get rewards for something they weren't part of also without slavery many black people in the present day will still be living in Africa not in North America. Another fact I have to say is that without the profits of slavery mankind would not have developed as much and many great inventions of humanity would have been made at a much later date due to the money slavery produced for the empire. By Faisal Ali
ReplyDeleteThe evidence for my claims that humanity had the means to create great inventions due to profits made by slavery is the cotton gin. The first modern cotton gin was invented in 1793 by an american inventor Eli Whitney the cotton gin was patented in 1794 this allowed the slaves to easily pick out the cotton fibers from the seeds even though the slaves had to work longer as the cotton gin made their work easier, more efficient and quicker but it was invented to the misfortune of the slaves as they had to work longer and harder due to the cotton gin being invented, but in today's modern era the cotton gin is used to benefit mankind as it allows us to cheaply, quickly and efficiently obtain cotton fibers which is then used to make clothes etc.
Deletesources:http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cotton_gin (the links you provided did not give me the info I needed to back up my claims)
the transatlantic slave trade was a inhumane act upon other humans and was a very bad example of persecution. the companies that were involved in this disgraceful act for example tate and lyle should pay compensation to the descendants because they had harmed their families and so on but i also disagree because the descendants did not go through the pain and torture that their families had suffered. by ismail aziz
ReplyDeleteYou need to use the information in the useful links to support your opinions
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThe slavetrade happend many years ago and even though britain were a big part of it they did not start it but they did help put a end to it and even though it may have shaped our world as it is today the slavetrade was wrong but it wasn't our fualt. People who are living now were not involved in trading as it was in the past so we shouldn't pay for what happend because the money gets taken out the tax that public pay. And if the goverment are still using or taking advantage of companies which were made by the slave trade to make money then the goverment is to balme for their actions and they are wrong to be selling us those things but they sell things which are every day needs so we need to buy them which Is not our fualt. So we should not have to pay to the decendants and anyway what happed then is not in anyway effecting their generation now because its not like they are going through the pain!
ReplyDeleteSairah and Ismail you need to use the information in the useful links page to justify your opinions.
ReplyDeleteFaisal please give details and examples to support your opinions.
I think that the transatlantic slave trade was the cruellest form of slavery and persecution, because the slaves got tortured for no reason and they didn't get paid for working. The slaves didn't get the rights that they were meant to have. The slaves got kidnapped so that's why they didn't get their rights. (If they didn't get kidnapped they could have got educated and worked and earned money for their families.) I think companies that were involved should pay compensation to the descendants, because the transatlantic slave trade was connected to the economies of three continents. This meant that a lot of slaves were traded with things like sugar and coffee. The slaves didn't get paid even though they worked really hard. The slave owners were that cruel that they didn't pay the slaves, so the slaves couldn't even provide enough food and shelter for their families. During the Transatlantic slave trade a lot of slaves were killed and they got inured, even though they weren't at fault. I think that compensation should be paid, because the slaves lives were ruined by their owners and the slaves couldn't even speak up for themselves. They had to take all the pain and they had to work hard and suffer and in return they didn't get anything that was beneficial or good for them. I think David Cameron, George Orwell, their ancestors and the slave owners shouldn't be paid compensation, because they are wealthy and they already have a lot of money. I think the descendants should be paid instead, because their families and generations had to work hard and take all the pain. The descendants didn't suffer but their families did so they should be paid the compensation.
ReplyDeleteThe transatlantic slave trade was a tragic and devastating in the black history timeline and also history in general. Though it happened many years ago, the slave had developed Britain and major companies in their wealthy state today. And the actions that happened in the slave trade were barbaric and persecution such as tearing family apart and separating them from their homes such as Olaudah Equiano,who was able to buy his freedom with the money he earned. These actions are not forgivable as it was cruel but to repair any damage colonies that had taken africans and force them to become slaves as compensation should be payed towards the DESCENDANTS OF SLAVES not the descendants of 'slave owners' as justice should be served whether they are dead upon their graves however they can at least pay compensation as that would be their sanction from the consequences made.
ReplyDeleteI agree that the transatlantic slave trade was a cruel and vile example of persecution but i don't agree that countries, companies and governments who were involved should try to repair the harm they caused.Because the countries involved would pay out compensation if they do pay out compensation who would they give it to?
ReplyDeleteThe slaves ancestors, but they weren't the ones who where captured,given a new identity and where treated in harsh conditions.
Also whose pocket would that compensation come out of?
Us,taxpayers and many of us don't want to pay compensation as Britain already is in a recession.And today everything is going up accept wages.
I think Britain should give and apology but not pay compensation.Britain should leave the past and first fix itself before paying out compensation.
Why?
Because in Britain there many people who are homeless,don't have jobs rather than trying to fix the past why don't you fix whats happening now than fixing something that happened 2 century ago.
the transatlantic slave trade was a disgrace to all of man kind and i think all the companies and countries who took part in it should be punished for their foolish mistakes. lots of companies have benefited from the slave trade and i think some of that wealth should go to the descendants of the slaves because their ancestors suffered through the torture. i also disagree that they should not be compensated and that is because the descendants did not go through the pain and torture but the slaves did. this auspicious day should be remembered for the courage and bravery of some slaves like olaudah Equiano,Harriet Tubman and Thomas Clarkson. lots of countries have made a lot of wealth throughout slavery and 1 of the main countries is Britain, although Britain played a major role in the transatlantic slave trade they also helped to abolish it so they should not be entirely blamed.
ReplyDeleteI think that the transatlantic slave trade was one of the worst forms of slavery. Of course the descendants of slavery should get compensation because these slaves were tortured and their future generations’ lives have been affected in a negative way. These slaves never got their human rights and were treated very badly and different than white people. Also future generations have been affected by this so they should receive money because of that. However, even though slavery existed many years ago, the outcomes were widespread across Britain still today. These companies that have become rich because of slavery should pay compensation to the descendants because they deserve it and they wouldn’t have become so rich if it wasn’t for their families (the slaves). Then again Britain is already in debt and giving compensation to things that have happened 150 years ago would place Britain in more debt. If the ancestors of slavery do get compensation, they will feel as if they have received justice. So my overall thought is that the descendants of slavery should receive compensation. Their future generations had to live thinking that their grandparents were slaves and were treated in a bad way. Some black people still get discriminated today. And because of slavery the descendants have to suffer as well as their families who were involved in it.
ReplyDeleteI think that the companies that benefited from the slaves and developed there company by slaves working and getting tortured should pay the compensation to slaves such as tobacco company because they should pay some because slaves worked on plantations to make tobacco so I think they should pay some compensation to the slaves and other company but it is mainly tobacco and they have a lot of money because people get addicted to cigarettes so they buy more and more so I think they should pay but I also disagree because why should they pay now its a bit late because if they pay the slaves relatives it don't make no sense because they weren't on plantations and getting tortured it was there ancestors so it think they shouldn't pay now because its late but overall I more strongly agree that they should pay compensation to slaves from company's and the slave owners.
ReplyDeleteHassan please check your work carefully. I am confused about whether you agree or disagree with the statement. All contributions must refer to the evidence.
ReplyDeleteTry and respond to what other people have said on the blog and please USE THE EVIDENCE IN THE LINKS PAGE TO SUPPORT YOUR OPINIONS.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI agree that transatlantic slave trade was a cruel and vile form of persecution. I think that companies, governments and countries that were involved should pay compensation to the descendants of the slaves because many slaves lost their lives, family and were degraded. Countries wouldn't be what they are today if it wasn't for the slave trade. Companies that benefited from slave trade wouldn't be as successful as they are/were. Slave owners also received a lot of money because of the slaves. First, when the slaves were working for them on plantations and secondly when slavery was abolished and they were paid compensation. Some descendants of the slave owners are still living off the enormous amount of money that was paid as compensation to their ancestors.David Cameron's ancestors were given the equivalent of £3m today. This is shown in the "Britain's Colonial Shame" article. I don't think it was wrong to pay the slave owner's compensation because slave trade was their livelihood. They also needed to provide for their families. However the way they treated the slaves was despicable and wrong. I think that the descendants of slave owner's should be the ones to pay compensation alongside the government because they owe it to them. Today they have different ways of income and benefits to make sure that they aren't poor unlike their ancestors. In conclusion I agree that the descendants of the slaves should be paid because it is the least the the countries, companies and governments can do to compensate for everything that their ancestors were put through.
ReplyDeleteI agree on the basis that the transatlantic was a inhumane and ignorant form of persecution. Companies governments and countries that were involved shouldn't pay compensation to descendants of slaves as the government's and companies in the past who did start the slave trade and thought of it as a form of persecution had a different set of minds, different philosophy's and different morals and ethics. They shouldn't pay as the descendants maybe criminals and why should they get money for people who they hadn't met and probably only cared about them until stories like David Cameron who got money from the slaves his ancestors owned, which caused Britain's colonial shame article. My point is the fact they could be in it for the money, companies which benefited of the slave trade didn't directly benefit as they got the money from trading with the slave owners, these companies include Big banks who give us money to do good. I also believe that companies shouldn't compensate as I believe everyone who is fit to work and capable enough, should earn their own money as people who are asking for compensation maybe doctors or dentists. One of my 'Life theory's ' is that you have a good life if you can provide food and a house for your family, people who are asking should thin about other people in third world countries who cant barely afford necessity's, in our society, If you need financial help, the government can help. In conclusion I think that they shouldn't be paid as they couldn't blame the ideology of the past.
ReplyDeleteI agree that the Transatlantic slave trade was a vile and inhumane form of persecution and I believe that the specific companies that benefited should pay up. The transatlantic slave trade boosted the profits of the companies associated with it like TSB and Tate and Lyle, and they may not have been as successful if it wasn't for the slaves and their hard work. Of course, money is just a material object and by no means will it bring back the African slaves or enable then to live their lives freely, but it is a good start as the African slaves would have wanted their descendants to be happy and financially secure.
ReplyDeleteOn the other hand, you must evaluate both sides the story and other people may argue that back in the time of the transatlantic slave trade, the companies were most likely to be run by different people with different mind sets, who believed different things. Their descendants now think differently, and it isnot their fault that their father or grandfather committed those wrongdoings
To conclude, I agree that the descendants should receive some sort of compensation, but what kind, I am not sure of. Personally I believe that instead of money, a large memorial to show respect would be best because it targets the actual slaves instead of their descendants. The memorial would be a good way for the descendants to realise that the companies are truly sorry for their ancestors actions, even though they cannot be changed.